Tucker
Chapter 4 - LOGAN
Tucker
Best friend who is finally marrying his partner this spring after three years of engagement.
Chapter 6 - Logan
Tucker
He joins Dean in teasing the couple through the shared group chat, claiming he always suspected their relationship was more than platonic.
Chapter 11 - Dean
Tucker
Is celebrated as Dean's best friend who is finally marrying Sabrina after three years of engagement, prompting reflections on their group's transition into adulthood alongside his daughter Jamie's upcoming third birthday.
Chapter 13 - Dean
Tucker
Remains unaware of Garrett’s proposal plans and continues to share daily photos of his daughter Jamie in the group chat. He is currently obsessed with fatherhood and encourages his friends to start families.
Chapter 14 - DEAN
Tucker / Tuck
Complains about the limousine being an extravagance until Garrett reveals it was arranged for free due to his status. Threatens to ruin John’s life if he proposes to Allie tomorrow, then enthusiastically agrees and imagines a future of shared milestones with the couple.
Chapter 16 - DEAN
Tucker / Tuck
Enters with Sabrina, towering over her while beaming. Receives a gruff but heartfelt congratulatory speech from Coach Jensen and shares a side hug with him.
Chapter 23 - Sabrina
Tucker / Tuck
Drinks champagne and observes a bickering couple in front of him while his wife contemplates her career path. He reassures her that he will adapt to whatever job she chooses, offering to handle more household duties, before noticing smoke on the plane and preparing for an emergency landing alongside her.
Chapter 25 - SABRINA
Tucker
Enjoys his honeymoon morning with Sabrina, reacts defensively to Alexander's arrival, throws the doll into the ocean with Sabrina, claims to be stung by a jellyfish while swimming, and endures teasing from Sabrina about almost letting a stranger treat his wound.
Chapter 26 - SABRINA
Tucker
Rests on a beach chair beside Sabrina while she reads, questions her fear of the ocean, and attempts to read her phone screen as she navigates group chat drama. He later texts his own male friends about Logan’s secret wedding.
Chapter 27 - SABRINA
Tucker / Tuck
Runs two successful bars in Boston that attract professional athletes, though he admits his capable staff leaves him with too much free time and causes restlessness. He conceals his work dissatisfaction from Sabrina to avoid adding stress during her final year of law school. He initiates a passionate encounter on a secluded path before being struck on the head.
Chapter 28 - TUCKER
Tucker / Tuck
Narrates his wife's recovery, takes the guys deep-sea fishing to clear his head, returns to find her sunburned, and witnesses the cursed doll wash up on shore.
Chapter 29 - SABRINA
Tucker
Admits to Sabrina that he feels bored and useless running the bars but concealed it to avoid pressuring her during her job search. Demands to be prioritized over her career and daughter, then storms off to town alone in the Jeep after their argument escalates on the beach. Is later arrested while out drinking.
Chapter 30 - SABRINA
Tucker
Released from jail after a stranger falsely accuses him of shoplifting and vandalism at a bar. Admits he has been brushing off his own unhappiness and feelings of neglect to avoid stressing Sabrina out, and promises to be more honest about his needs going forward. Reaffirms his commitment to supporting her and Jamie while agreeing to postpone career stress discussions until they return home.
Chapter 34 - GARRETT
Tucker
Sends congratulatory messages in a group chat after the awards ceremony and confirms he threw Alexander the doll into the ocean during his honeymoon, earning Garrett’s approval.
Chapter 43 - GARRETT
Tucker / Tuck
He is noted as the only father Garrett knows and will soon move away from Boston, prompting Garrett's quiet disappointment over losing his closest parental confidant.
EPILOGUE
Tucker
Drops off a large gift bag for the expecting couple, revealing that his daughter selected two dolls from a cursed series. He cheerfully recounts the dolls' dark histories and accompanies the group to the medical appointment.