Joe Hayes

Chapter 21 - DEAN

Joe Hayes

Greets Dean with immediate hostility and questions his familiarity with Allie’s nickname before interrogating him about his hockey statistics and law school prospects. Reveals a past as a Boston College Frozen Four champion and a professional scout, then drops a turkey platter due to physical tremors while accusing Dean of being an entitled rich kid who would abandon Allie if her life becomes difficult.

Chapter 29 - ALLIE

Joe Hayes

Reads a hockey physics book while waiting for his daughter, then delivers a harsh warning about the fragility of her relationship with Dean based on his own marital struggles and Dean's sheltered upbringing. Celebrates Christmas Eve with her, giving her cash and watching a film to mark the occasion.

Chapter 34 - ALLIE

Joe Hayes / Mr. Hayes

Reports a sprained wrist and ambulance visit to Allie, then initially resists Dean’s presence before bonding over sports and pizza. He explains the origin of Allie’s custom perfume, reveals her late mother Eva’s fluency in French, and agrees to relocate to Los Angeles if it supports Allie’s acting career.